Morten St George Theory

[Linda]

Linda, I think you and the others should know that my theory about the Cathar fortress is not based solely on what we see on the rosettes folio. There are other pointers to the Cathars, including:

i. The men and women of the roundtables.

There is not a smidge of evidence to identify these as Cathars other than your saying so.
In my mind they are representatives of various societies.

ii. The baptismal ceremony of consolamentum.

There is not a smidge of evidence to identify these as Cathars other than your saying so.
*If* it is a baptism, it could be Catholic just as easily as Cathar. I dont think it is a baptism at all.

iii. Efforts to evade procreation.

There is not a smidge of evidence to identify these as Cathars other than your saying so.
*If* it is related to procreation, it could be anyone. I don't think it is related to procreation at all.

iv. The legend that Christian Rosenkreutz was educated by the Cathars.

And this relates to the vms how and proves what?

And more, a lot more. 

More of the above? More of nothing but your sayso? All you are doing is picking out visuals, placing a story on them that is not necessarily there, and presenting this as evidence.

So you see, to my thinking, it has to be Montségur. End of story.

Yep i guess that is end of story if you are going to hold onto your beliefs in the face of obvious problems with them being pointed out, supported with actual evidence (I am referring to Vviews' information about Montsegur).