I agree, this is the best of such reviews I've read so far. Well researched and balanced.
Edit: I hadn't read the last bit yet, where the author leaps from the observation that the plants aren't naturalistic to speculating that the whole MS is likely meaningless...
Edit: I hadn't read the last bit yet, where the author leaps from the observation that the plants aren't naturalistic to speculating that the whole MS is likely meaningless...