24-02-2017, 04:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 24-02-2017, 09:32 PM by Torsten.
Edit Reason: correction
)
(24-02-2017, 02:32 PM)ReneZ wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.In any case, for me y is another character that cannot be mapped to a letter.
If one glyph cannot be mapped to a letter then the same is true for all other glyphs of the VMS. Let me explain this conclusion with [y], [o] and [a] as example.
[y] can replace [o] and [a]. Moreover (deleted - see next post)
Within the network of similar words [y] is used instead of [a] as last glyph in a word. For instance [dar] without [r] results in [dy] or [okal] without [l] results in [oky]:
aiiin( 41) daiin ( 17) odaiiin( 4) okaiiin( 4) qokaiiin( 2) kaiiin( 3) taiiin ...
aiin (469) daiin (863) odaiin (60) okaiin (212) qokaiin (262) kaiin (65)
ain ( 89) dain (211) odain (18) okain (144) qokain (279) kain (48)
an ( 7) dan ( 20) odan ( 2) okan ( 5) qokan ( 8) kan ( 3)
aiir ( 23) daiir ( 23) odaiir ( 2) okaiir ( 6) qokaiir ( 3) kaiir (--)
air ( 74) dair (106) odair ( 5) okair ( 22) qokair ( 17) kair (14)
ar (350) dar (318) odar (24) okar (129) qokar (152) kar (52)
ail ( 5) dail ( 2) odail (--) okail ( 1) qokail ( 1) kail ( 1)
al (260) dal (253) odal (13) okal (138) qokal (191) kal (23)
am ( 88) dam ( 98) odam ( 6) okam ( 26) qokam ( 25) kam ( 9)
os ( 29) dos ( 1) odos (--) okos ( 8) qokos ( 1) kos ( 3)
or (363) dor ( 73) odor ( 8) okor ( 34) qokor ( 36) kor (26)
ol (537) dol (117) odol ( 2) okol ( 82) qokol (104) kol (37)
y (151) dy (270) ody (46) oky (102) qoky (147) ky (25)
For word types having an [y] the glyph [y] is used in 3096 out of 4148 cases (74.6 %) as last glyph whereas [a] is used as last glyph in 73 out of 3760 word types (1.9 %). For this reason the word [chedy] occurs 501 times whereas the word [cheda] occurs only once.
For [o] this rule is less strict. [o] occurs in 314 out of 6920 word types (4.5 %) as last glyph for words including [o]. For instance beside [chy] (155 times) also [cho] exists 68 times and the word [chedo] occurs two times within the VMS. (Deleted since both instances of [chedo] are most likely transcription errors.)
My conclusion is that [y] is used as spelling variant for [a] and [o]. This means if [y] cannot be mapped to a letter then the same is true for [a] and [o].

