16-05-2021, 08:09 PM
Uncalibrated years are nothing else than a different way of referring to the percentage of C-14 contents.
The relation between the two is linear in the time frame of interest.
Averaging the uncalibrated years is the same as averaging the C-14 percentages.
Furthermore, the uncertainty in a date of any sample is far greater than the typical duration of creating a book. Of course, there are exceptional cases where this could have taken decades, but there is no particular reason to believe that this is the case for the Voynich MS.
What most people don't realise is that we have been very lucky. The best guess for the origin of the book, at the time that the experiment was prepared, was 1460-1470-ish. Had this been true, the result would have looked very different indeed, because the calibration curve is much flatter here.
When I have more time, tomorrow, I can show an example of such a case, and the rather horrible date estimate that may result from it.
The fact that the calibrated uncertainties are much smaller than the uncalibrated ones is exactly a consequence of the very favourable slope at the start of the 15th century.
The relation between the two is linear in the time frame of interest.
Averaging the uncalibrated years is the same as averaging the C-14 percentages.
Furthermore, the uncertainty in a date of any sample is far greater than the typical duration of creating a book. Of course, there are exceptional cases where this could have taken decades, but there is no particular reason to believe that this is the case for the Voynich MS.
What most people don't realise is that we have been very lucky. The best guess for the origin of the book, at the time that the experiment was prepared, was 1460-1470-ish. Had this been true, the result would have looked very different indeed, because the calibration curve is much flatter here.
When I have more time, tomorrow, I can show an example of such a case, and the rather horrible date estimate that may result from it.
The fact that the calibrated uncertainties are much smaller than the uncalibrated ones is exactly a consequence of the very favourable slope at the start of the 15th century.