• Options
• Login
• Desktop Style

Scribe counting

• Index

  • The Voynich Ninja
  • Voynich Research
  • Analysis of the text
  • Scribe counting
• Scribe counting

• Scribe counting

  RobGea > 02-05-2022, 07:58 PM

  Here are the numbers and folios, i get from Lisa Fagin Davis'  "How Many Glyphs and How Many Scribes?" paper.
  
  If someone could check this data, that would be great. (see Note )
  
  Summary
  Scribe_1:  113 pages :: Herbal, Pharma,  57v(circular text),
  Scribe_2:  046 pages :: Herbal, Balneo,   rose dorse,            [12 lines on f115r]
  Scribe_3:  033 pages :: Herbal, Recipes,  (bifolia 58/65 and 94/95)
  Scribe_4:  027 pages :: Cosmo  (circular foldouts and astrological diagrams), Rosette
  Scribe_5:  007 pages :: Herbal (bifolia 41/48)  , bifolia 57/66 [except for 57v])
  
  
  Scribe_1:
  

  Code:

  ['f1r', 'f1v', 'f2r', 'f2v', 'f3r', 'f3v', 'f4r', 'f4v', 'f5r', 'f5v', 'f6r', 'f6v', 'f7r', 'f7v', 'f8r', 'f8v', 'f9r', 'f9v', 'f10r', 'f10v', 'f11r', 'f11v', 'f13r', 'f13v', 'f14r', 'f14v', 'f15r', 'f15v', 'f16r', 'f16v', 'f17r', 'f17v', 'f18r', 'f18v', 'f19r', 'f19v', 'f20r', 'f20v', 'f21r', 'f21v', 'f22r', 'f22v', 'f23r', 'f23v', 'f24r', 'f24v', 'f25r', 'f25v', 'f27r', 'f27v', 'f28r', 'f28v', 'f29r', 'f29v', 'f30r', 'f30v', 'f32r', 'f32v', 'f35r', 'f35v', 'f36r', 'f36v', 'f37r', 'f37v', 'f38r', 'f38v', 'f42r', 'f42v', 'f44r', 'f44v', 'f45r', 'f45v', 'f47r', 'f47v', 'f49r', 'f49v', 'f51r', 'f51v', 'f52r', 'f52v', 'f53r', 'f53v', 'f54r', 'f54v', 'f56r', 'f56v', 'f57v', 'f87r', 'f87v', 'f88r', 'f88v', 'f89r1', 'f89r2', 'f89v2', 'f89v1', 'f90r1', 'f90r2', 'f90v2', 'f90v1', 'f93r', 'f93v', 'f96r', 'f96v', 'f99r', 'f99v', 'f100r', 'f100v', 'f101r', 'f101v', 'f102r1', 'f102r2', 'f102v2', 'f102v1']

  
  Scribe_2:
  

  Code:

  ['f26r', 'f26v', 'f31r', 'f31v', 'f33r', 'f33v', 'f34r', 'f34v', 'f39r', 'f39v', 'f40r', 'f40v', 'f43r', 'f43v', 'f46r', 'f46v', 'f50r', 'f50v', 'f55r', 'f55v', 'f75r', 'f75v', 'f76r', 'f76v', 'f77r', 'f77v', 'f78r', 'f78v', 'f79r', 'f79v', 'f80r', 'f80v', 'f81r', 'f81v', 'f82r', 'f82v', 'f83r', 'f83v', 'f84r', 'f84v', 'f85r1', 'f85r2', 'f86v4', 'f86v6', 'f86v5', 'f86v3']

  
  Scribe_3:
  

  Code:

  ['f58r', 'f58v', 'f65r', 'f65v', 'f94r', 'f94v', 'f95r1', 'f95r2', 'f95v2', 'f95v1', 'f103r', 'f103v', 'f104r', 'f104v', 'f105r', 'f105v', 'f106r', 'f106v', 'f107r', 'f107v', 'f108r', 'f108v', 'f111r', 'f111v', 'f112r', 'f112v', 'f113r', 'f113v', 'f114r', 'f114v', 'f115r', 'f115v', 'f116r']

  
  Scribe_4:
  

  Code:

  ['f67r1', 'f67r2', 'f67v2', 'f67v1', 'f68r1', 'f68r2', 'f68r3', 'f68v3', 'f68v2', 'f68v1', 'f69r', 'f69v', 'f70r1', 'f70r2', 'f70v2', 'f70v1', 'f71r', 'f71v', 'f72r1', 'f72r2', 'f72r3', 'f72v3', 'f72v2', 'f72v1', 'f73r', 'f73v', 'fRos']

  
  Scribe_5:
  

  Code:

  ['f41r', 'f41v', 'f48r', 'f48v', 'f57r', 'f66r', 'f66v']

  
  Note:
  A possible cause for confusion is the pharma folios viz:
  f101r  and You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
  f101v1- foldout sometimes classed as 2 folios, sometimes just one You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. ie TT-ivtff-0a
  
  Here i have ['f101r', 'f101v' ] and not counted  'f101r2' --Is that an error or not...discuss

• RE: Scribe counting

  nablator > 02-05-2022, 09:25 PM

  I counted 101r and 101v as two pages each for scribe 1 and 115r both for scribe 2 and 3 (because of first 12 lines).
  
  Thanks.

• RE: Scribe counting

  LisaFaginDavis > 03-05-2022, 07:24 PM

  Looks good to me!
• Next Oldest Next Newest