[split] VMS - a forgery?

[-JKP-]

There is indeed a split camp on it being a forgery versus a real manuscript....

There are all sorts of theories, but one has to look at the reasoning behind the theory, and at the person's credentials, track record, and credibility.

If Einstein puts forward some ideas on physics and some person who clearly doesn't know what they are talking about (whether they realize it themselves or not) puts out an alternate theory, obviously the first idea has more credibility.

Just because there are split camps does not mean the opposing ideas have equal value. You have to weigh them.