(31-10-2026, 08:41 PM)npcompl33t wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.Guttman horseshoes appear when there is a dominant sequential ordering. why text would experience a dominant sequential ordering. I've shared textbooks and multiple papers that describe this effect.
Its true 'time' may not be the dominant sequential ordering, but I have yet to discover such a signal in Text where that wasn't the case. I'm happy to look at any examples someone might suggest.
In the horseshoe thread, you can see examples of books with different topics, orthographic shifts, and more. The only example text statistics exhibited a horseshoe was napiers casebooks, which were written as a log over several years, and the horseshoe verifiably tracked time in that case.
I think all what you said is right, yet I feel like this discussion is not fully settled yet: I also believe @quimqu when he says he finds an horseshoe in his Skribe data.
Let me try to set one point clear. I'm not talking about sections. Those are an input to @quimqu's Skribe (he also just posted elsewhere about confirming your results about sections). I think it's estabilished by now they are real (which was long known) and that they are textually linked (as you, quimqu and Lisa demonstrated best). It's no surprise your model and quimqu's Skribe find similar a distribution at the sections level: so I guess the horseshoe found by quimqu is caused by the sections structure. But what about your horseshoe? Surely sections affect it too, but is yours different from quimqu's so it's possible to say there's also a textual ordering at bifolios level (as your last thread about margin distance and text slant angle also support)?

