The Voynich Manuscript’s positional entropy collapse

[Dunsel]

All of this is checkable in a few minutes by anyone with the volumes to hand, and all of it is correctable in an erratum. I make no claim here about the paper's methodology or its conclusions; that is a separate discussion, and I may come back to it.

Timm,

Jesus Christ. You spent all that time counting pages and inventing "errors" like some unpaid librarian with a grudge. The Bennett citation was a typesetting error for the 1976 book; the rest of the points are either minor or disputable.  The paper stands on the data and the method. If you have a substantive critique of the entropy results or the cipher model, put it in writing with numbers. Otherwise this is just bibliography nitpicking.

Rod