01-11-2016, 06:37 PM
Ah!, silence. That's the answer. Heraldry fails because of silence.
I have put forward heraldry as a method of investigation for tub patterns in the VMs Pisces and Aries pages. Various objections have been offered. I have offered a response, as above.
It cannot be logically supported that the painter of the VMs can be labelled as sloppy and lacking in knowledge of the subject and, at the same time, be fully relied upon to supply to a specific location, the most intimate of details in a completely atypical technique that requites a very high level precision.
It seems like a reasonable reply, but...
I have put forward heraldry as a method of investigation for tub patterns in the VMs Pisces and Aries pages. Various objections have been offered. I have offered a response, as above.
It cannot be logically supported that the painter of the VMs can be labelled as sloppy and lacking in knowledge of the subject and, at the same time, be fully relied upon to supply to a specific location, the most intimate of details in a completely atypical technique that requites a very high level precision.
It seems like a reasonable reply, but...