[Article] Voynich Article in The Atlantic

[Koen G]

I definitely agree that the author put a lot of time, effort and dedication into this article. He does not quote most people he talked to directly, but it all shaped the article into a solid narrative. I can see some instances where he clearly took into account what I talked to him about. Also, afterwards I was contacted by a separate fact checker who wanted me to confirm (or deny) some claims from the article. A mention of non-crazy amateur research would have been nice, but overall I was impressed by their dedication.

Rene: who is "we", that's a very good question, and a tricky one. "We" probably wouldn't be able to agree on that, either