12-04-2024, 05:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2024, 06:06 PM by Mark Knowles.)
What qualifies Newbold, Wilfred Voynich, Brumbaugh, Gordon Rugg as experts on Voynich dating?
I suspect that some of the others you cite as experts when it comes to dating the manuscript are nothing of the kind.
If your answer is that they have academic qualifications. My answer is that their qualifications are not in fields relevant to Voynich dating.
As far as the other experts that you list I would ask you in each case how you justify including them as an expert in Voynich dating and precisely what their statement regarding dating is. I am not saying there are no people with relevant skills in this regard, but your idea of who are experts is not mine.
I suspect that some of the others you cite as experts when it comes to dating the manuscript are nothing of the kind.
If your answer is that they have academic qualifications. My answer is that their qualifications are not in fields relevant to Voynich dating.
As far as the other experts that you list I would ask you in each case how you justify including them as an expert in Voynich dating and precisely what their statement regarding dating is. I am not saying there are no people with relevant skills in this regard, but your idea of who are experts is not mine.