15-07-2020, 09:34 PM
Hi Rob,
I'm a bit hesitating (because you obviously put certain effort in this!) to tell you that you got it wrong again.
No, that's wrong. A word must exist (>=1 times) at least in 1 Herbal page (not in 1 page only). Suppose we had 24 Herbal pages where each Zodiac sign is associated to two different plants (2x12 = 24). Then each word would exist in 2 Herbal pages.
Of course I suppose that with that large number of Herbal pages there will be no Zodiac signs left without associated plants - hence "must" (vs "may").
The point is that two different words shall not exist in the same Herbal folio simultaneously. It's OK if Aries exists in 10 folios, and Libra exists in 13 folios, as long as they do not coexist in one and the same folio.
No, this requirement is an excess constraint. On the contrary, I believe that Zodiac names rather would not occur in Zodiac pages, and, on the whole, I have a feeling that there is utmost caution there by not including plant names in plant folios, not including Zodiac names in Zodiac charts, not including continent names in T-O-maps, etc. Which is really very, very clever - or some really weird side effect of the whole design.
So in a nutshell, there are no requirements or constraints outside of the Herbal folios, the search can be done just against the 128 Herbal folios ( (which is 129 without f65r).
I'm a bit hesitating (because you obviously put certain effort in this!) to tell you that you got it wrong again.
Quote:A word must exist( >=1 times ) in 1 Herbal page only
No, that's wrong. A word must exist (>=1 times) at least in 1 Herbal page (not in 1 page only). Suppose we had 24 Herbal pages where each Zodiac sign is associated to two different plants (2x12 = 24). Then each word would exist in 2 Herbal pages.
Of course I suppose that with that large number of Herbal pages there will be no Zodiac signs left without associated plants - hence "must" (vs "may").
The point is that two different words shall not exist in the same Herbal folio simultaneously. It's OK if Aries exists in 10 folios, and Libra exists in 13 folios, as long as they do not coexist in one and the same folio.
(15-07-2020, 08:29 PM)RobGea wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.that word must also exist( >=1 times ) in 1 zodiac page only
No, this requirement is an excess constraint. On the contrary, I believe that Zodiac names rather would not occur in Zodiac pages, and, on the whole, I have a feeling that there is utmost caution there by not including plant names in plant folios, not including Zodiac names in Zodiac charts, not including continent names in T-O-maps, etc. Which is really very, very clever - or some really weird side effect of the whole design.
So in a nutshell, there are no requirements or constraints outside of the Herbal folios, the search can be done just against the 128 Herbal folios ( (which is 129 without f65r).