Diane!
It seems your ambitions and mercantile interests prevail the interest to the VMs research. I really can't imagine that you want to help someone.
Critique?
As much as I can remember, expedient constructive critique, better to say - discussion and remarks never were forbidden on this forum. Clear and detailed criticism on a particular issue is rather useful, it lets opponent understand a mistake or, in another case, gives a possibility to put forth counter arguments or to clarify the point which was misunderstood or poorly developed. Even if both will reserve their own opinion, readers can see arguments from the both sides and decide which are stronger.
As for the "methodology", everyone has the right to apply his own approach. Different approaches is not a bad thing, especially when the standart one gives no result. No matter that some are obviously wrong, any sensible researcher can distinguish such approaches without assistance.
Actually, I prefer to know weak spots of my own theory and approach than to seek for them in theories of another researchers.
It seems your ambitions and mercantile interests prevail the interest to the VMs research. I really can't imagine that you want to help someone.
Critique?
As much as I can remember, expedient constructive critique, better to say - discussion and remarks never were forbidden on this forum. Clear and detailed criticism on a particular issue is rather useful, it lets opponent understand a mistake or, in another case, gives a possibility to put forth counter arguments or to clarify the point which was misunderstood or poorly developed. Even if both will reserve their own opinion, readers can see arguments from the both sides and decide which are stronger.
As for the "methodology", everyone has the right to apply his own approach. Different approaches is not a bad thing, especially when the standart one gives no result. No matter that some are obviously wrong, any sensible researcher can distinguish such approaches without assistance.
Actually, I prefer to know weak spots of my own theory and approach than to seek for them in theories of another researchers.