13-11-2018, 10:41 PM
(13-11-2018, 04:18 PM)Diane wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.-JKP -
I absolutely agree with you that most Voynich theories - purporting to be 'history'-narratives - would never pass peer review. (i.e. by historians specialising in the period's political, economic and social history).
So I gather you agree with my proposal? The forum should have a separate heading for those sort of discussions?
...
I'm probably the worst person on the forum to ask that question because I have almost zero interest in VMS history as interpreted by other people.
I'm interested in the VMS itself and in primary sources. What people said 30 or 50 years ago and who said it first doesn't matter to me. I'm not using their research. I haven't seen their research. I'm looking at the VMS and anything else I can find in libraries or on the Internet that relates directly to the VMS, without being filtered through someone else's perceptions. Reading about Wilfrid's assertions is useless to me.
I'm not against the idea. There might be other people on the forum who want to discuss it. It's just not of interest to me.