The solid argument against commissioning is the "aror sheey" marginalia in the last folio. The reasoning is as follows:
1. A commissioned work would not feature idle marginalia. Hence, marginalia were left by the purchaser (or even later owner)
2. However, "aror sheey" seems to be written in at least one of the same hands as the main corpus. Hence, it was left by the creator.
These two contradict each other.
1. A commissioned work would not feature idle marginalia. Hence, marginalia were left by the purchaser (or even later owner)
2. However, "aror sheey" seems to be written in at least one of the same hands as the main corpus. Hence, it was left by the creator.
These two contradict each other.