05-12-2017, 10:53 AM
(05-12-2017, 09:09 AM)Searcher wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.If we don't know whether it is a calendar or a horoscope, or a natal chart, or something else, we can call it Zodiac or astrologic section easily.
That's basically my opinion at the moment. We don't know what it is so it's okay to call it Zodiac section, I don't know anything more convenient.
My issue is that the main participants in the discussion don't properly distinguish between "a Zodiac" and "Zodiac signs", greatly confusing things. If Rene asks for a definition which shows why "the zodiac section in the Voynich MS would *not* be a zodiac?" then that's misleading because the section cannot be a Zodiac.
Rene: the file name said folding calendar with month images (free translation from German) but "Monatsbilderzyklus mit Tierkreiszeichen" similarly illustrates my point. A Monatsbilderzyklus with Tierkreiszeichen cannot be a Tierkreis, while you would call it so.