some questions about Voynich language and charactor

[februs]

In the current, Voynich language is understood like Arabic language or surrounding language?

and about characters..

I think..

    ＝ a       
    ＝ ch
    ＝ yy
    ＝ z

are these right?

I have a wish.
I want to know correspondence alphabet and all characters of VM.
do you know a site written about them?

[bi3mw]

The decoding of the alphabet is speculative at this stage. Secured letters do not exist. However, there are different theories which contain a resolving of the alphabet. Here an example ( page 4 ):

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

[februs]

really??

Monica Yokubinas built the thread  'Stars identified' in astrology category.

she corresponded VM letters and ancient Arabic.

I see it is correct, not a coincidence.[url=https://ejje.weblio.jp/content/a+coincidence][/url]
I think it can't spring up coincidence.

[ReneZ]

Really!!

The proposed solution of Monica Yokubinas is just one of very, very many.

There is nothing special about this one, compared to all the others.

[februs]

>ReneZ

but Monica's correspondence is very similar about name of constellation in VM language and Arabic.

can it spring up in coincidence?

I want detailed explanation of it..(´-ω-`)

I can't think that Monica's interpretation VM language and ancient Arabic are similar in coincidence.
so I think that Monica's interpretation is about correct. (´・ω・`)

[tavie]

Go look at the many other threads for competing theories.  There are maybe about 50. You'll find that each one has a claim along the lines of "It can't be a coincidence."

(Spoiler alert: they are coincidences.)

[MarcoP]

A while ago, I posted an explanation of Monica's method.
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

but Monica's correspondence is very similar about name of constellation in VM language and Arabic.

I don't have time to look at the details, but You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. (not only constellations). In Ptolemy's catalogue, more than 1000 stars were listed and many stars have and had different names. Since Monica can pick from many possible readings for each Voynichese word (as my Reddit post shows), she is able to find a "similar" star name in most of the cases. Of course, it is also necessary to take huge liberties, like saying that "Achayayaz" is a plausible spelling for "Mirzan Al-Jawza", or throwing the Latin constellation name "Auriga" into a mix of pseudo-Arabic star names.

[februs]

>tavie

ok, I will read them.


>MarcoP

but  written stars on 68r are better bright stars, for example they are 1～3 magnitude stars.
so they don't exist 1000 pieces. so I can't think that it is in coincidence.

in the reason, I think that VM language is similar ancient Arabic.

[Monica Yokubinas]

A while ago, I posted an explanation of Monica's method.
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.

but Monica's correspondence is very similar about name of constellation in VM language and Arabic.

I don't have time to look at the details, but You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. (not only constellations). In Ptolemy's catalogue, more than 1000 stars were listed and many stars have and had different names. Since Monica can pick from many possible readings for each Voynichese word (as my Reddit post shows), she is able to find a "similar" star name in most of the cases. Of course, it is also necessary to take huge liberties, like saying that "Achayayaz" is a plausible spelling for "Mirzan Al-Jawza", or throwing the Latin constellation name "Auriga" into a mix of pseudo-Arabic star names.

you still have no idea of my method.

[februs]

I am interesting Monica's theory.

I read her's site. I funned it.