![]() |
|
One author, working a season at a time — an idea about the different hands - Printable Version +- The Voynich Ninja (https://www.voynich.ninja) +-- Forum: Voynich Research (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-27.html) +--- Forum: Theories & Solutions (https://www.voynich.ninja/forum-58.html) +--- Thread: One author, working a season at a time — an idea about the different hands (/thread-6322.html) |
One author, working a season at a time — an idea about the different hands - TDFCM - 22-11-2026 Hello. I'm not an academic. I run a machine shop and I've been interested in this book for years, as an amateur. I have an idea about how it was made. I haven't seen this exact idea posted anywhere, so I wanted to put it up and find out where it breaks. First, where the idea comes from, because it isn't from books. When I was a kid, my friend lived with his dad. His parents were divorced. His dad was schizophrenic, and I was at their house a lot, so I knew his dad's artwork well — the walls were covered with it. Later I met his mom. She was schizophrenic too, and she lived in a different house. Her walls had the same kind of artwork on them. I actually asked her why his work was at her house. She was a little offended. They were divorced. It was her work, not his. Two people, living apart, with the same illness, making art that looked like it came from the same hand. That stuck with me, even though I mostly forgot about it for years. Then I saw a video about the Voynich manuscript, and the pictures hit me the same way. It looked exactly like their work. So here is the idea. I think the book was written by one person. This person had money, or their family did. They were mentally ill, in a way that made them write and draw this stuff for their own reasons, in a system they made up themselves. They were kept out of sight, but the people who loved them gave them what they needed to work. That was normal for a family with money. They hid their weaknesses. It's also why there would be no record of this person anywhere else — the family would have made sure of that. The silence around this book isn't an accident. It was the plan. Six hundred years later, nobody has a name, a house, or a grave to point to. That's not a family failing to keep records. That's a family succeeding at hiding someone. I should say plainly: I have no idea whether the author was a man or a woman, and nothing in this idea depends on it. I know Kennedy and Churchill said something like this in 2004 — that the book might be glossolalia, or outsider art. Mine is close to theirs, with a couple of differences I think matter — the family supplying the work, and one explained below. The problem everybody runs into is the different hands. Davis found five different scribes in 2020. The word habits change when the handwriting changes. Inside one hand, the writing doesn't drift — it stays the same from that hand's first page to its last. And the hands take turns, sheet by sheet. Five people working together explains all of that. But five people means somebody taught five people a writing system that exists nowhere else on earth, and then all of them kept it secret forever. No letters, no second book, no mention of it anywhere. Secrets with that many people in on them usually get out. One person is simpler. But one person has to explain why their writing changes in clean jumps instead of slowly wearing down. My answer is that this person worked in bursts. A season at a time. Maybe every fall, after the harvest was in. Maybe summers spent somewhere they were allowed to work on it. Then they'd stop for most of a year, and start again. I think that explains the jumps, for two reasons. One: quills. These pens were cut by hand and they wore out fast. If you put your writing down for months and pick it up again with a new quill you cut yourself, at a different desk, your writing changes all at once. Then it stays steady while you work. Then you stop, and next year it changes again. That gives you steady hands with sharp edges between them, which is what the book shows. Two: the writing system was theirs, and only theirs. It wasn't written down anywhere else and nobody else used it. So every time they came back to it after a year away, they had to remember their own rules. Memory isn't perfect. They would settle back into it a little differently each time — this year they write a word one way, next year a slightly different way becomes the habit. That's why the word habits change at the same places the handwriting changes. A normal writer has a whole language around them keeping them consistent. This person had nothing around them but their own memory. The sheet-by-sheet swapping of hands may not even be the author's doing. Layfield and Davis argued this year that the sheets were probably written as loose sheets and only put together into a book later, by a binder who couldn't read them. If that's right, the binder shuffled them. The author didn't. One objection I expect is that the book is too neat and organized for a sick person. That one I think has an answer. Obsessive-compulsive traits would explain the perfection — the neatness, the strict order, the same forms repeated exactly, page after page. Being ill doesn't mean being sloppy. Sometimes it means the opposite. The same traits answer something that bothered me: there are almost no corrections in the whole book, and someone re-learning their own system every year should make mistakes. A person like that doesn't cross out a mistake and move on. The sheet gets thrown away and copied over. The mistakes happened — they just never survived, because the author couldn't stand to leave one on a finished sheet. All we have is the clean copies. And sheets are missing from this book — at least fourteen leaves, going by the old page numbering. Some of that is just six hundred years, no doubt. But a book written by someone who threw away every sheet with a mistake on it would end up with gaps in it. What I really can't explain, I'll say up front, is the report of two sheets where the hands may be mixed. If those are real, and both hands are on one sheet from the same sitting, my idea has a real problem, and I'd like to know which sheets they are. There might be a way to test this. Check whether each hand used its own batch of ink, and whether each hand's sheets came from their own group of calf skins. Different batches would mean the work was done at different times, in separate stretches — which is what I'm claiming. One batch of ink and mixed-up skins all the way through would mean it was all done in one long push, and my idea is probably wrong. As far as I know, the ink testing that was done (McCrone, 2009) only checked that the materials were right for the time period. It didn't compare batches hand by hand. If I'm wrong about that, tell me. I know theories like this are hard to prove or disprove. I've tried to say what would change my mind. Tell me where it breaks. — T. RE: One author, working a season at a time — an idea about the different hands - ololololo - 22-11-2026 |