1 hour ago
Oops, typo: If you had to choose, who penned the two Voynichese words on f116v?
I'm sure this has been discussed here and there but I've been meaning to poll the forum on this one. I'd love to hear LFD's input especially.
Obligatory textbook disclaimers:
Here's my own personal, subjective, amateur opinion on this:
I'm sure this has been discussed here and there but I've been meaning to poll the forum on this one. I'd love to hear LFD's input especially.
Obligatory textbook disclaimers:
- I know we only have 2 vords to go off
- A hand doesn't always write the same glyph the same way
- Even if the handwriting resembles one of the main hands, we can't conclude it's original
- Ultimately, none of us know the answer to who penned the f116v; it's OK to just make a wild guess for the exercise acknowledging there's virtually no way to know for sure the author(s) of the vords.
Here's my own personal, subjective, amateur opinion on this:
Although Hand 2 doesn't write mechanically this way always, I think there's a fair comparison to be made between H2 and the Voynichese vords on f116v, especially Q14 Hand 2.
Below is a cherrypicked (read: non-representative & biased) sample on H2 letterforms that resemble f116v's:
[attachment=19143]
Here's a composite side-by-side comparison:
[attachment=19145]
Now, time for another disclaimer: I wouldn't say this is even strong evidence for claiming H2 penned the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. or any other text on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. for that matter. I personally I think it could have been penned by somebody else, perhaps another scribe, perhaps most probably a later owner given the sheer number of hands it must have gone through. But if I personally see some resemblance between You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. Voynichese and the rest of the text; especially considering other copies like Th. Pet.'s transcription or Fabrizio Salani's copy do not match the letterforms quite as You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. IMHO, making it entirely plausible that those two words (not necessarily the rest of f116v) could have been written by a VMS scribe
Below is a cherrypicked (read: non-representative & biased) sample on H2 letterforms that resemble f116v's:
[attachment=19143]
Here's a composite side-by-side comparison:
[attachment=19145]
Now, time for another disclaimer: I wouldn't say this is even strong evidence for claiming H2 penned the You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. or any other text on You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. for that matter. I personally I think it could have been penned by somebody else, perhaps another scribe, perhaps most probably a later owner given the sheer number of hands it must have gone through. But if I personally see some resemblance between You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. Voynichese and the rest of the text; especially considering other copies like Th. Pet.'s transcription or Fabrizio Salani's copy do not match the letterforms quite as You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view. IMHO, making it entirely plausible that those two words (not necessarily the rest of f116v) could have been written by a VMS scribe