The Voynich Ninja

Full Version: How many people could have written the Voynich?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2
(22-10-2021, 07:26 PM)R. Sale Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.The VMs artist or artists had a level of sophistication sufficient for mnemonics and heraldic canting, and an imagination for fantastic plants,
I am sure the author  did not see the plant with a root like the eagle (Carniolan coats of arms), or a plant with two Swabian lions. You probably noticed that the white Aries and his sheep have a black counterpart. It could be a reference to White and Black Ghibellines and their supporters.
(22-10-2021, 08:26 PM)cvetkakocj@rogers.com Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.You probably noticed that the white Aries and his sheep have a black counterpart. It could be a reference to White and Black Ghibellines and their supporters.
I have not heard of the White and Black Ghibilines, I wonder if you are referring to the White and Black Guelphs. They are, however, Florentine, so I don't quite see how they fit with your Alsatian, Viennese, Slovenian individual.
(22-10-2021, 02:40 PM)bi3mw Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.It can be assumed that about 90 percent of the population in the Middle Ages belonged to the lower class of working peasants. The rest was distributed among the clergy and nobility. The growing cities took a special position (quote: "City air makes you free".) Citizens could, depending on their profession, develop relatively freely and their share of the population grew steadily. Statistically, they are counted among the third class.
If the population in Europe in 1400 was 78 million, then the share of the clergy and nobility in Europe was about 7.8 million people. However, it may be necessary to distinguish between the author of the manuscript and the donor. It can be assumed that the VMS was quite expensive to produce and that a member of the lower clergy, for example, could not afford it. Nevertheless, he could practically be able to write the manuscript. The number of those who could finance the VMS is therefore much smaller than the number of potential authors. The assumption that it could be about 2 percent of the population I consider realistic.
The author would have be reasonably intellectual. I am not talking about Voynich specific knowledge, that is something else, just someone with enough intelligence that they might consider such an undertaking. What percentage of our group might fit that?

Also I wonder what percentage of our collection of individuals would have enough in the way of surviving records that we could find their name today. Ideally what percentage of those individuals might turn up somewhere on a Google search even if only the smallest of mention.
(23-10-2021, 01:08 PM)Mark Knowles Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.The author would have be reasonably intellectual. I am not talking about Voynich specific knowledge, that is something else, just someone with enough intelligence that they might consider such an undertaking. What percentage of our group might fit that?

I am not sure if this is a question of intelligence, but one had to be quite eccentric to start such a project. This attribute could be an important clue in the search for "the needle in the haystack", i.e. the author / donator of the VMS. Of course, this limits the group of people within our assumed 2 percent even more.
(22-10-2021, 08:41 PM)Mark Knowles Wrote: You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.I have not heard of the White and Black Ghibilines, I wonder if you are referring to the White and Black Guelphs. They are, however, Florentine, so I don't quite see how they fit with your Alsatian, Viennese, Slovenian individual.
Sorry, Mark, I was writing off memory and I mixed the two. By the time VM was written, the Guelphs were fighting among themselves and were referred to Imperial and Papal party. The situation is described in the book  written by  Gabriele Rosseti Disquisitions on the antipapal spirit, which can be found online. The book also explains how religious symbolism was used to criticize the Church (particularly in the works of Dante and Petrarch). It is in this spirit that the VM should be interpreted.
As to the Bavarian, Swabian, and Vienna connection - this connection goes back to the time  of the Ottonian dynasty and to St. Hemma of Gurk. St. Hemma was  the descendent of Emperor Henry II. He named Welf III as the Duke of Carinthia. 
Her grandmother  Hemma was granted the mining rights in Lieding (near Strasbourg) by Emperor Otto II in 975. Hemma was born in Peilenstein in the Mark an der Sann( Pilštanj in present day Slovenia) and was brought up at the Imperial court in Bamberg by Emperess St. Cunigunde. Hemma married the Carinthian count William II of Friesach, known as Margrave an der Sann. Both her husband and two sons were murdered.
The relationship with Emperor Henry must have been through the Emma of Altdorf, the daughter of Welf I, Count of Altdorf in Alamannia. 


The history  is vailed in mystery. One thing remains: the opposition to the powers that were writing the history has always find the way to leave some clues in the symbolic esoteric language.

At the time VM was created, the Counts of Celje were one of the wealthiest European families. According to historical sources, they have their origin in the Lords of Sanneck, the relatives of St. Hemma of Gurk.  In the early 14th century, the Lords Sanneck allied with the Austrian Habsburgs in their conflict against Duke Henry VI of  Carinthia. After saving the life of King Sigismund (of Luxemburg), King of Bohemia, Hungary and Croatia, the Sanneks (Saunecks) were elevated to Counts and they adopted the name Counts of Cilli (named after their castle in Celje, Slovenia).  Herman of Celje also became Sigismund's father-in-law. 
The Counts of Celje and the Habsburgs had the contract of mutual inheritance and when the last Count of Celje died, most of their property was regained by the Habsburgs.

The Counts of Celje were apparently more wealthy than the Emperor and were related by marriages to most European families. 

They were strong supporters of the Slovenian Carthusian monasteries. They founded the monastery of Pleterje where Kempf had been prior for several years. They could easily supply him with the expensive parchment.
The battle of Nicopolis, 1396

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login to view.
Pages: 1 2